Projects Researchers Publications Patents Monographs
 
 

Title: Exploring the Indian Ocean for seamount cobalt-rich ferromanganese crusts

Project Leader:
Banakar, V.K.

COBALT METAL FACTS

Cobalt (Co) is one of the most essential elements for the humankind. It has several strategic and irreplaceable industrial applications. It is a silvery metal with close packed hexagonal crystal structure. Its common properties are as follows:

Density = 8.85 g/cm3, Melting point = 1493°C, Boiling point = 3100°C
Atomic number = 27, Valency = +2 & +3

Co has the property of retaining its strength even at very high temperatures, and hence is used extensively in superalloys, surface coatings, high-speed steel, high-temperature cutting tools, cemented carbides etc.

Co can retain ferromagnetic property up to a temperature of 1100°C, which is highest for any other metals. Therefore, it is used in manufacturing of Alnico magnets, recording tapes, soft magnetic material, alloys for spacecraft etc.

Co in conjunction with silica produces intense deep blue colour and hence is used in manufacturing of paints and enamels.

Co as acetate is an effective catalyst, hence extensively used in oil refineries. Apart from these usages Co is finding increasing application in electronic industry.

Co is 33rd abundant metal in the earth's crust but is highly scattered. Exploitable concentration is found in several countries, out of which, 17 countries presently produce this metal either from its own land resources (12 countries) or by refining imported slag and scrap (5 countries). Co is mostly associated with copper, nickel, and arsenic ores. In 2003 nearly 40 % of the world production came from nickel ores. Presently the world production of Co stands at around 42000 tonnes, and current land deposits are estimated to last for over 100 years. Co mining is active in Australia, Brazil, Belgium, Canada, China, Cuba, Morocco, Zambia, South Africa. India is one of the countries that refined nearly 500 tonnes of Co during 2004 from imported slag concentrates from Congo and Cuba. In most of the cases Co is produced as byproduct of Ni and Cu mining. The pure (99.8 %) Co metal price rose to as high as ~28 $ per lb (60 $ / Kg) in recent past and is again low at ~US$ 15/lb (Source: www.thecdi.com ), but the price is highly variable. In view of the importance of cobalt metals we felt it worth exploring marine regime for the cobalt-deposits.


Team Members:
Dr. Rajiv Nigam
Dr. Abhay Mudholkar
Sh. G. Parthiban
Sh. R. Manimurali
Sh. D. Gracias
Dr. Anjali Chodankar
Ms. Rajani Ramesh
Sh. Sanjay Rana

Dr. N. B. Bhosle
Dr. P. A. Loka Bharati
Dr. N. Ramaiah
Sh. K. P. Krishnan
Ms. Ranjita Harji

 


WHAT ARE THESE DEPOSITS
Ferromanganese encrustations (Fe-Mn Crust) containing on an average >1% of cobalt metal can be designated as Co-rich crust. The Co-rich crusts accrete at shallow water depth (generally <2500 m) as slabs capping the seamounts. They are 3-6 times more enriched in Cobalt metal than the abyssal polymetallic nodules and deep-water crusts. Ferromanganese crusts are hydrogenous colloidal precipitates, which are known to record oceanographic conditions contemporaneous to their growth period. The Co-rich crusts are purely hydrogenetic precipitates, wherein the cobalt concentration was shown to relate inversely with their growth rate. The primary requirements for Co-rich crust formation are:
a) Availability of sediment free hard substrate
b) Fairly oxic ambient water
c) Large supply of oxidizable Mn

Such conditions are generally found on seamounts rising in to the OMZ, where a large supply of dissolved Mn can be expected due to intense oxidation of the organic matter. In the water column the Mn- and Fe-oxides occur together as colloidal flocks. Below the OMZ (generally below 1000 m depth in northern Indian Ocean) oxidizable-Mn availability is large and hence, the crusts forming at this depth enrich mangalophile elements like Mn, Co, Pb etc. Cobalt and other metals are fixed by lattice substitution for Mn4+ in the MnO2. Another pathway of Cobalt enrichment is due to its ability to oxidise on the surfaces of MnO2 colloids to Co3+, which is less soluble and more stable than other minor metals. This is the reason why the seamount ferromanganese crusts formed closer to OMZ tend to enrich cobalt over other transition metals. It is also worth noting here that the Co-rich crusts do concentrate platinum (up to 2.5 ppm) compared to deep-water Fe-Mn nodules. Therefore, the seamount ferromanganese crusts have attracted the attention of mineral explorers.

The Fe-Mn crusts cap most of the shallow-water seamounts in the world oceans. The seamount Fe-Mn crusts deposited in inactive-hydrothermal regions are exclusively of hydrogenetic origin because of non-availability of diagenetically remobilized metals due to sediment starvation. Most of the transition- and alkali-metals are preferentially removed from the ambient water by adsorption on to the negatively charged surfaces of MnO2 colloids, while negatively charged ions preferentially bind to the slight positively charged FeOOH phase during the Fe-Mn crust formation. Hydrogenous Fe-Mn crusts accumulate by slow accretion (<10 mm/ Ma) of Fe-Mn oxyhydroxides precipitated from the ambient seawater. The slow growth rate allows for effective adsorption of considerable quantity of minor elements by the oxyhydroxide colloids during the process of Fe-Mn crust accretion. The Fe-hydroxide precipitate forms the beginning layer during the hydrogenetic accretion of the crust oxide, which subsequently catalyses the oxidation of Mn. The further growth process of the Fe-Mn crusts is believed to be autocatalytic. The dominant controls on the concentrations of elements in the Fe-Mn crusts include the concentrations of metals in seawater, surface-charge and -area of the colloidal particles, and growth rate.

The seamount Fe-Mn crusts exhibit enrichment of metals over the seawater composition by several orders and most dominantly enriched metal species are the transition group comprising Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, V, Pb, Zn, etc. The second group of elements that is enriched is the REE and followed by ultra-trace metal such as platinum group metals. Although considerable work has been done on the Fe-Mn crusts of the world oceans, the studies on Indian Ocean Fe-Mn crusts are limited. Particularly the studies on ANS Fe-Mn crust are extremely sparse and were based on samples collected from a single dredging-operation in the upper flank of the ANS (see Banakar et al. 1997, Marine Geology; Parthiban and Banakar, 1999, Indian Mineralogist).

Exploring for new mineral deposits generally depends on its utility, cost, and availability on the land. As far as India is concerned, no workable deposits of cobalt have been located. Low-grade non-workable deposits of Co have been reported from Singbhum district of Bihar. According to Cobalt Development Institute cobalt-metal market is extremely complex and volatile. Hence, the economics of the Cobalt-Crust mining and metallurgy requires expert opinions, and is out of the scope of present information.

EVOLUTION OF THE PROJECT

Subsequent to the first recovery of cobalt-enriched Ferromanganese Crusts in 1994 from the Afanasiy-Nikitin Seamount (ANS) on board RV. Sidorenko (See Banakar et al., 1997, Marine Geology), the National Institute of Oceanography initiated in-house R & D Project. The samples for this R & D project were collected on board R.V. A.A. Sidorenko. We conducted only one dredging operation on the ANS at 3°S Latitude & 83°E Longitude in the Equatorial Indian Ocean, which yielded nearly 70 kilograms of samples. The samples were mainly composed of Fe-Mn oxide deposits on hard carbonate substrates with cobalt content up to 0.8 %. The detailed physical and chemical description, and potential of those samples as indicators of palaeoceanographic conditions have been reported in Banakar et al (1997). We have traced some interesting palaeoceanographic changes such as, major drop in global sea level during the Oligocene, lowering of oxygen content in the intermediate depths in the region during Late Miocene, and signatures of intensified Himalayan erosion at the close of Miocene.

After the first-time recovery of cobalt enriched ferromanganese crusts from the ANS, we proposed a project to DOD for funding, which received funding for X 5-Year Plan period. The Indian western-EEZ also hosts several small seamounts, which were also thought to provide interesting sites for cobalt-crust exploration. Thus exploring the cobalt-crusts on the Indian Ocean seamounts (particularly ANS and Indian EEZ-Seamounts) was the main objective of the submitted proposal. However, we have built-in R & D program with the main exploration objective, as we felt that the samples to be collected potentially contain valuable clues on past oceanographic changes. Additionally, collecting possible water column data to provide some baseline environmental parameters and to understand equatorial water biogeochemistry were also incorporated in the project. Thus the evolved project is multidisciplinary in nature.

The ANS in Equatorial East Indian Ocean (EEIO) was discovered during the RV. Vityaz cruise of 1959 by Russian scientists, and was shown to have formed during the Late-Cretaceous. The ANS has evolved as a part of 85° E Ridge. Although, the Russian researchers have extensively explored this seamount with the help of 'Mir' submersible, the cobalt-enriched ferromanganese crusts were discovered only during 1994, onboard R.V.Sidorenko by NIO scientists. Subsequent to its emplacement the ANS has undergone tectonic disturbances due to intraplate deformation episodes in the region as evidenced by numerous criss-cross faulting of the seamount. The seamounts in Laxmi Basin (western EEZ of India) viz. Raman Seamount, Panikker Seamount, and Wadiya Guyot have been previously mapped by the multibeam and details are available in Bhattacharrya et al., (1994, Marine Geodesy). Although the sedimentation rate in this region is very high, the occurrence of Fe-Mn crusts may be expected because of very strong OMZ in the overlying water. Further, the samples (rocks and Fe-Mn crusts) from these seamounts may hold important evidences to address their controversial origin. Few locations on the Lakshadweep Ridge were also considered for sampling.


Afanasiy-Nikitin Seamounts in Equatorial Indian Ocean

Some specimen of cobalt-enriched Fe-Mn crusts from the Afanasiy-Nikitin Seamounts in the Equatorial Indian Ocean

We have successfully recovered cobalt-enriched (cobalt metal content up to 0.9 wt. %) ferromanganese crusts from the Afanasiy-Nikitin Seamounts from several locations ranging in water depth from 1600 m to 3200 m. The samples are being studied in detail to understand genetic aspects of these deposits and palaeoceanographic conditions prevailed during their formation.

We plan to explore all the prominent underwater mounts in the Northern Indian Ocean. We have obtained some encouraging results from the seamounts of Laxmi Basin in Eastern Arabian Sea and also seamounts of Lakshadweep Sea. The samples collected will be utilized to assess the Cobalt-metal resource in the marine regime and also to understand the past oceanographic processes. We have plans to continue this projects in XI 5-Year Plan Period, so that at the end of the project, we shall have adequate information on the occurrence of Cobalt-rich deposits in the seas surrounding us.

The Co-Crust team has also undertaken few interesting investigations such as reconstruction of biogeochemical responses to the climate change utilizing sediments from the northern Indian Ocean; modern phytoplankton productivity; microbial activity in Cobalt-crusts; lipid geochemistry etc.